How bids are marked
Most tenders are marked on quality and price, for example 60% quality and 40% price. The tender documents tell you the split and how each question is scored.
Each written question is usually marked from 0 to 5 by two or three people who read every bid against the same guide:
| Score | What it usually means |
|---|---|
| 5 Excellent | Answers every part in detail, with evidence, and gives the buyer confidence |
| 3 Good | Answers the question, but some parts are general or not backed up |
| 1 Poor | Misses parts of the question or just repeats what they asked |
| 0 | No answer, or it doesn't answer the question |
Some questions are pass or fail, such as insurance levels or holding an accreditation. Fail one and the rest of your bid is not read, so check them first.
Before you start
- Check the pass or fail requirements. Insurance, turnover, accreditations, licences. If you can't meet one, move on.
- Read everything once. The specification tells you what they want; the questions tell you how you'll be judged.
- Note the deadline and the clarification deadline. Ask questions early through the tender website. Everyone sees the answers.
- Gather your bid pack: policies, insurance certificates, case studies, references. See Documents you'll need and the templates.
Writing each answer
Use the quality answer planner. For each question:
- Answer what they asked, in the order they asked it. Use their headings and words, so the marker can tick off each part.
- Show you understand their situation. One or two sentences about what matters to them: a school that can't have noise during exams, residents who need notice before work starts.
- Say how, not just what. "We will" with names, steps, times and equipment beats "we can" and "we are committed to".
- Use the word limit, not more. Anything over the limit is usually ignored.
- Write plainly. Short sentences, no jargon, no padding. Markers read dozens of bids.
Evidence
Every claim should have proof: a similar job you did, a number, a certificate or a quote from a client. "We always arrive on time" scores less than "We attended 96% of 412 call-outs for a housing association within two hours last year". Keep two or three case studies ready, and ask past clients now whether they will be referees.
Social value
Public bodies have to consider the wider benefit of what they buy, and central government gives social value at least 10% of the marks. Councils often do similar. Small local firms can score well here: local staff, an apprentice, buying from local suppliers, helping a community group. Make specific, measurable promises and say how you will report them. The social value template gives a structure.
Pricing
- Fill in the pricing schedule exactly as asked. Missing lines or changed formats can get a bid rejected.
- When quality is weighted you rarely need to be cheapest. Price to do the job properly.
- Use Contract history to see what similar contracts went for, and how many firms bid.
- An unusually low price may be investigated, and you may be asked to justify it.
Common mistakes
- Missing the deadline. Tender websites close to the minute; submit the day before.
- Copying an answer from another bid without changing the client's name.
- Not answering part of a question.
- Out-of-date insurance certificates or policies.
- Not asking for feedback when you lose. Buyers must tell you your scores, and it's the fastest way to improve.
General guidance, not legal advice. Always follow the instructions in the tender documents.